Gated vs. Ungated Content: The Smart Marketer's Guide to Balancing Value and Conversion

In the world of B2B marketing, few debates are as enduring as the one surrounding gated versus ungated content. Should you lock valuable resources behind a form, offer them freely, or find a middle ground? Let’s break down this nuanced discussion, leveraging insights from Dan Saavedra, founder of Merger Data, a signal analytics firm specializing in uncovering buyer intent through data.

Whether you're a marketing leader or part of a marketing team, chances are you’ve grappled with these questions. Today, we’ll dive into the merits of gated, ungated, and partially gated content and share actionable strategies to optimize your approach.

What Is Gated Content?

Imagine a gatekeeper outside a club—you only get in if you meet their requirements. Gated content works the same way: it restricts access to valuable resources in exchange for user information, such as an email address.

Why Gated Content Works:

• Filters High-Intent Leads: Only highly interested prospects will exchange their contact information for access.
• Establishes Value: A gate signals exclusivity and worth, prompting serious inquiries.
• Reduces Noise: Helps focus sales efforts on qualified leads, minimizing time wasted on uninterested parties.

However, gated content can feel “hostile.” It may deter low-intent visitors or those hesitant to share their personal information without first building trust.

The Ungated Philosophy

Ungated content is open to everyone. There are no barriers—no forms, no commitments. This approach prioritizes visibility and audience engagement.

Pros of Ungated Content:

• Maximizes Reach: Without restrictions, your content can be accessed and shared widely.
• Supports Retargeting: Platforms like Google or LinkedIn enable retargeting visitors with paid ads.
• Builds Trust: Freely available resources position your brand as helpful and transparent.

But there’s a catch. Without collecting user data, you lose direct ways to re-engage with your audience, relying solely on retargeting ads or hope that visitors return on their own.

Why Partial Gating Is a Game-Changer

Partial gating blends the best of both worlds. Think of it like a beautiful garden leading to a gated treasure. You provide value upfront (like a sneak peek) and hold back the rest for users willing to share their contact information.

How Partial Gating Works:

1. Frontload Value: Offer a compelling snippet of your content for free.
2. Introduce a Cliffhanger: Add a subtle barrier (e.g., an email gate) to unlock the remaining content.
3. Offer High-Value Resources: Ensure what’s behind the gate is worth the exchange.

Why It Works:

• Increases Engagement: More users interact with the free portion, and high-intent visitors will take the next step.
• Captures Key Data: By gating only the most valuable parts, you collect contact information without alienating potential leads.
• Better Signal Data: Partial gating helps you understand the customer journey, from initial interest to eventual conversion.

Optimizing Your Gating Strategy

Here’s how to decide which content to gate, ungate, or partially gate:

1. Gated Content

Use for:

• High-value resources (e.g., detailed reports, whitepapers).
• Assets tailored for high-intent buyers.
  Example: A downloadable pricing guide or industry-specific benchmark report.

2. Ungated Content

Use for:

• Thought leadership pieces (e.g., blogs, social posts).
• Brand awareness efforts.
  Example: Educational videos or infographics designed to attract top-of-funnel visitors.

3. Partially Gated Content

Use for:

• Popular ungated resources with strong performance.
• Highly targeted assets aligned with your ideal customer profile (ICP).
  Example: A blog post offering key insights upfront, with deeper analysis gated behind an email form.

Examples of Partial Gating in Action

1. Blog Post with Gated Expansion
   Share 30% of a valuable blog post for free, then require an email to access the rest.
2. Video Preview with Email Unlock
   Provide a sneak peek of a video and gate the full version behind a form.
3. LinkedIn Posts with Gated Links
   Post high-value snippets on LinkedIn and link to gated content for deeper engagement.
4. Reports with Free Excerpts
   Allow access to the first two pages of a detailed report, with the full version gated.

Key Takeaways

• Choose Gating Wisely: Use gates selectively for high-value resources.
• Collect and Utilize Data: Gather user data to track the customer journey and enable targeted outreach.
• Be Gentle: Avoid overloading leads with communications. Focus on building trust and relevance.
• Balance Value and Conversion: Always offer enough upfront value to justify the ask behind the gate.

By leveraging partially gated content, you’ll not only generate leads but also collect valuable signal data to enhance your marketing strategy.

For more tips and tools, check out the Signal Constructor Workbook by Dan Saavedra, designed to help you set up actionable signals that drive results.

Have thoughts on gating strategies? Drop a comment below or share this post with your team. Let’s keep the conversation going!

‍